I woke up this morning to the news of Dallas. The same way I woke up to the news of Orlando. And 9/11. And San Bernardino. And Paris. And Brussels. And in all of those cases, I heard the same message: “The only way you can defeat hate is by love.”
We have heard that countless times now, in the face of countless tragedies. You would think at some point it would take hold. Sure, there are always going to be people who kill for sport and those who can’t tell the difference between right and wrong, but surely the rest of the population can figure out that violence and hate make the world a darker, crueler, more dangerous place to live. The only way to crush hate is by love, not more hate. Humanity created the light bulb. Surely we can figure this out.
With the amount of people reiterating the “beat hate with love” idea, however, I don’t think recognizing it is the issue. I think what most people forget is that there’s another step before simply loving someone.
Last January, I went to SEEK, a giant Catholic retreat in Tennessee. While I was there, I listened to a talk titled, “The Most Dangerous Four Letter Word.” As I was waiting for the talk to start, I ran through the obvious possibilities in my head. Hate. Love. Fear. Nuke (ok, fine, that one was after the talk… still, it’s a very dangerous four letter word).
It wasn’t any of those words. It was something far more thought-provoking and far more troublesome.
The word was THEM.
I’m not going to lie, the speaker lost me for a minute, but then he explained that the word THEM is almost dehumanizing. We take real people and we turn them into a faceless group whom we are free to hate. Because they are no longer individuals. They are simply part of a mob.
This is the most dangerous aspect of our world right now. Because we no longer recognize our enemies as people with real problems who love and make mistakes and have goals and beliefs and fears. It’s us versus them. And you see this every day. In every country.
I’ll never forget one article I read about an ISIS fighter. He and his brother, both from war-torn Syria, had joined ISIS because there was no other way to make money. Another article I read mentioned a fighter who was forced to join because otherwise the other ISIS fighters would have taken his sister. But when we envision ISIS, our enemy, we don’t think about those people. We think of the fighters who rape and kill and loot and who take pride in doing so.
I am not making excuses for the people in ISIS. But if we can no longer recognize them as people, if we can no longer recognize that situations and outside events helped shape their decisions, then we can never defeat anyone. Both sides will always find excuses to hurt the other because it will always be us versus them. ISIS is simply a terrorist group. And we are free to hate them.
This feeling isn’t confined to America, either. It’s the same on the other side. When a Middle Eastern nation (you could insert North Korea, Iran, parts of Iraq, and maybe even Russia) thinks of America, it doesn’t think of the ordinary American people. It simply thinks of an empire. And you can hate empires.
It’s not just nation against nation. It’s everywhere. Blacks versus whites. Cops versus blacks. Conservatives versus liberals. The US versus Hispanic immigrants. The West versus the Middle East. It goes on and on and on. And no one wins.
Because if you make the conflict into us versus them, one person of the THEM is no different than the rest. Brent Thompson is no different than Jeronimo Yanez. A Muslim is no different than an ISIS fighter. Philando Castile is no different than Mumia Abu-Jamal. Minnesota leads to Dallas, Iraq and Afghanistan lead to Paris and Brussels and San Bernardino, and routine traffic stops become deadly encounters.
If we turn a conflict into us versus them, then we have already lost. Because we can hate them. We can silence them. We can torture them. We can kill them. We are free not to love them.
Yes, hate can only be defeated by love. But first, we have to recognize that there are people to love. People with names. People who are not simply THEM. If we want to defeat hate, this is imperative. To quote Beetee from The Hunger Games: Mockingjay: “We have to stop viewing one another as enemies. At this point, unity is essential for our survival.”